Why We Make Poor Choices in Love and Life

Navigating relationships and personal decisions is challenging. Many of us repeatedly attract or choose people and situations that drain us, even when we try our best. Understanding why we make poor choices helps us break toxic patterns and create healthier, more fulfilling relationships. This article explores the science behind decision-making, the role of self-love, and practical steps to choose better. All sources are linked for further exploration.


Beyond the Law of Attraction: Understanding Poor Choices

Many people believe we simply “attract” what we experience. While this idea is popular in self-help circles, it only tells part of the story. Research shows that our choices depend on self-esteem, emotional regulation, attachment patterns, and learned behaviors. The Law of Attraction may set the stage, but our conscious and unconscious decisions ultimately determine who and what we allow into our lives.

Even when we are aware of our patterns, we often repeat poor choices because the brain prefers familiarity, especially under stress.


The Science of Poor Choices: Decision-Making in Relationships

Self-Esteem, Anxiety, and Risk

People with lower self-esteem and higher anxiety tend to make risk-averse decisions in relationships. They often stay in unsatisfying or harmful situations because change feels riskier than discomfort.

“Lower self-esteem and higher anxiety levels were associated with more risk-averse choices for personal decisions but not for decisions for others.” — Journal of Behavioral Decision Making

By understanding this, we can consciously make choices that support our growth rather than maintain familiar pain.


Attachment Styles and Emotional Regulation

Attachment theory shows how early relationships shape expectations and behaviors in adulthood. Insecure attachment (anxious or avoidant) often leads to difficulties in emotional regulation. This increases the likelihood of staying in toxic relationships.

“Attachment avoidance was associated with emotion suppression, which in turn affected psychological well-being.” — Journal of Personality

Recognizing these patterns allows us to break cycles of emotional suppression and poor communication.


The Role of Self-Love in Breaking Toxic Patterns

Self-Compassion and Mental Health

Self-compassion means treating yourself kindly during suffering. Studies show it improves emotional regulation and mental health. In fact, emotional regulation often mediates the benefits of self-compassion. In other words, self-love actively helps us make better decisions and cope with stress.

“Emotion regulation significantly mediated the relationship between self-compassion and mental health.” — Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being


Self-Esteem and Relationship Quality

High self-esteem predicts healthier, more satisfying relationships. Conversely, toxic relationships erode self-worth, creating a feedback loop (Harris & Orth, 2019; Wood et al., 2023). Interventions that boost self-esteem and self-compassion can help us break this cycle.

“Relationships and self-esteem reciprocally predict each other over time with similar effect sizes.” — Journal of Personality and Social Psychology


Why We Stay: The Psychology of Familiar Pain

People repeat painful patterns because their nervous system and subconscious mind prefer predictability. Under stress, the brain defaults to familiar behaviors, even if they are unhealthy (Inwood & Ferrari, 2018). Awareness alone is not enough; we must also create emotional safety to make new choices.

“When your nervous system is dysregulated, your brain prioritizes safety over wisdom.”


Coping Strategies and the Path to Healing

Emotion-Focused Coping

Journaling, self-reflection, and other emotion-focused coping strategies help process feelings and gain clarity. These practices assist in breaking cycles of poor choices .

“Emotion-focused coping included practices like journaling and self-reflection, which helped participants process their emotions.” —


Seeking Social Support

Confiding in trusted friends or family provides reassurance and practical advice. Social support is essential for resilience and recovery from toxic dynamics.


Practical Steps: Choosing Better, Loving Better

  1. Recognize Patterns: Identify recurring themes in your relationships and choices.
  2. Practice Self-Compassion: Treat yourself kindly, especially when you notice self-sabotaging behaviors.
  3. Set Boundaries: Healthy boundaries protect your energy and communicate expectations.
  4. Seek Support: Reach out to friends, family, or professionals.
  5. Regulate Your Emotions: Mindfulness, journaling, and therapy help calm your nervous system.
  6. Choose Differently: Every moment is an opportunity to make a new choice; small changes ripple outward.

Conclusion: Self-Love as the Foundation for Better Choices

Breaking toxic patterns is not about blaming yourself or others. It is about reclaiming your power to choose. Self-love is essential for healthy decision-making and fulfilling relationships. By understanding the science behind your choices and practicing compassion, you can transform your life from the inside out.

Explore more resources on The Self-Love Journey Blog for emotional healing, boundaries, and personal growth.

Scroll to Top